• Need more information on these or other topics? Ask an information specialist at (312) 422-2050 or rc@aha.org

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 311 other followers

  • Share this blog

    Share |
  • Note:

    Information posted in this blog does not necessarily represent the views of the American Hospital Association
  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Top Posts

  • Top Rated Posts

GOVERNANCE: How many members on governing board?

The average size of a health care governing board is 13 to 16 members, according to a 2015 survey conducted by The Governance Institute.  This article, written by a governance consultant, describes the traditional model for a hospital board – the community board model.  Reasons why health systems are exploring other models are discussed.  These other models include:

  • Mirror boards
  • Community board at the parent company level only
  • Board of experts
  • Committees only at the system board level
  • CEOs of subsidiary hospitals report directly to system CEO

Source: Stout, L.R. (2017, March-April). Breaking free from traditional models. Healthcare Executive, 32(2), 72-75.  Click here for publisher’s website: http://ache.org/HEOnline/digital/heonline_index.cfm  Posted by AHA Resource Center (312) 422-2050 rc@aha.org


How many hospitals have nurses on the governing board?

I found this intriguing table tucked away in an article that compared responses of nurse executives to surveys taken in 2011 and 2013.  The question was whether the institution has nurses on the governing board.  There is no aggregate statistic for hospitals as a group, but here are the responses for urban versus rural hospitals:


  • 65 percent yes (rural hospitals)
  • 62 percent yes (urban hospitals)

How do these percentages resonate with your experience at your hospital?

Source: Pittman, P., Bass, E., and Hargraves, J. (2015, Feb.). The future of nursing: Monitoring the progress of recommended change in hospitals, nurse-led clinics, and home health and hospice agencies. JONA. The Journal of Nursing Administration, 45(2), 93-99.  Click here to access publisher’s website:

http://journals.lww.com/jonajournal/Citation/2015/02000/The_Future_of_Nursing__Monitoring_the_Progress_of.8.aspx    Posted by AHA Resource Center (312) 422-2050, rc@aha.org

National Health Care Governance Survey – Benchmark Results

The average hospital board size is 12, while the average system headquarters board is sized at 16. Three quarters of hospital boards include a physician, and one third include a nurse. Boards met an average nine times annually. Trustee compensation was offered by 12% of hospital/system boards. These are some of the findings from a new national health care governance survey recently released by the American Hospital Association’s Center for Healthcare Governance.

The report looks at hospital and health system governing board practices in these areas:

  • Board composition size and diversity
  • Board structure, including term limits, meeting frequency, board compensation, and committees
  • Board selection
  • Board orientation and education
  • Board evaluation
  • CEO performance and compensation
  • Quality and strategy oversight
  • Internal and external stakeholders, covering physician and clinical staff alignment, understanding community health needs, and the IRS Form 990
  • Board culture, such as executive sessions, meeting disccussion, and electronic board portals
  • Readiness for health care transformation

Source: 2014 National health care governance survey report. Center for Healthcare Governance, 2014. http://www.americangovernance.com/resources/reports/governance-reports/2014/

Posted by AHA Resource Center (312) 422-2050 rc@aha.org

Diversity and Disparities: a Benchmark Study of U.S. Hospitals in 2013

Three key ways hospitals and health systems can address disparities in health care are:

  1. Increase the collection and use of race, ethnicity and language preference [REAL] data to identify where disparities exist
  2. Increase cultural competency training to ensure caregivers and other staff have a deeper understanding of diverse patients and their individual needs
  3. Increase leadership and governance diversity

A new survey report looks at what hospitals are doing on these 3 fronts, learning more about the strategies used and providing benchmarks for gauging hospital progress.

Top line survey results found:

  • Most hospitals are actively collecting patient demographic data — 97% collect data on race, 94% on ethnicity, and 95% on primary language.
  • 86% of hospitals provide cultural competency training to clinical staff, while nearly 65% require all employees to attend diversity training.
  • Minorities comprise 14% of hospital trustees, 12% of executive leadership, and 17% of first- and mid-management positions.
  • Nearly a third of patients are from a minority group.

Meanwhile, a new report from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Urban Institute compares how the U.S. and European Union approach eliminating health disparities. One key difference: the U.S. has focused primarily on racial/ethnic disparities rather than economic inequities, although they are often intertwined.


Diversity and disparities: a benchmark study of U.S. hospitals in 2013. Institute for Diversity in Health Management; Health Research & Educational Trust, 2014. http://www.diversityconnection.org/diversityconnection/leadership-conferences/diversity_disparities_Benchmark_study_hospitals_2013.pdf

Docteur E; Berenson RA. In pursuit of health equity: comparing U.S. and EU approaches to eliminating disparities. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation; Urban Institute, June 2014. http://www.rwjf.org/content/dam/farm/reports/issue_briefs/2014/rwjf414060

Related sources:

Earlier benchmarking surveys: 2011 2009

Equity of Care web site, a collaboration of the American College of Healthcare Executives, American Hospital Association, Association of American Medical Colleges, Catholic Health Association of the United States, and America’s Essential Hospitals. Accessed June 25 at http://www.equityofcare.org/

Posted by AHA Resource Center (312) 422-2050, rc@aha.org

CORPORATE CULTURE: Guide for organizational ethics

“Over time, an organization may lose its soul.”  That grabs your attention.  This article presents and describes an organizational ethics guide developed by Catholic Health East to help avoid that kind of erosion of mission and values.  The guide is short and consists of the following three categories of questions that can be applied to value-based decision-making:

  1. Significant organizational decisions
  2. How does ethical review of policy work?
  3. Considering organizational culture and behavior

How several hospitals in the CHE system have formalized this process through the establishment of board-management committees is also discussed briefly.

Source: Sanders, A.  Sustaining a commitment to mission and core values.  Health Progress;94(3):72-77, May-June 2013.  Click here for publisher’s website: http://www.chausa.org/HP/  Posted by AHA Resource Center (312) 422-2050, rc@aha.org

Practice Benchmarks on Non-profit Health System Governing Boards

A study of the governance structure of the 14 of the largest nonprofit health systems in the US is detailed in this new report. With an eye toward ongoing improvement, the report provides benchmarking data on governance practices in the following areas:

  • Board structure, including consecutive term limits, voting board member limits, board size, board composition, board committees and executive committees, and perceived effectiveness of committees
  • Board processes, covering board accountability, board chair-CEO relationships, board and CEO evaluation processes, succession planning, boards role in patient care quality and in community benefit, and allocation of board time and effort
  • Board culture, such as  approach to decision-making, board development, senior staff support for the board, and executive sessions

Emerging governance patterns are identified. The study collectively scores systems [not by name] on effective governance practices and correlates that with overall system patient care performance, based on Thomson Reuters [now Truven] 100 Top Hospitals methodology. While not the primary focus of the study, the researchers found a correlation between effective  governance scores and some patient care measures, but not with the overall aggregate patient care performance measures used. An appendix to the report highlights a selected governance feature each participating system provided.

The systems that participated in the study were:

  1. Adventist Health System Sunbelt Healthcare
  2. Ascension Health
  3. Banner Health
  4. Carolinas HealthCare System
  5. Catholic Health East
  6. Catholic Health Initiatives
  7. Catholic Health Partners
  8. Christus Health
  9. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals and Health Plan
  10. Mayo Clinic
  11. Mercy Health
  12. Providence Health & Services
  13. Sutter Health
  14. Trinity Health

Source: Prybil L and others. Governance in large nonprofit health systems: current profile and emerging patterns. Commonwealth Center for Governance Studies, 2012. http://www.mc.uky.edu/publichealth/documents/Governance_booklet_FINAL.pdf

Related sources:

Foster D. Hospital system membership and performance; top 100 hospitals research. Truven Health Analytics, May 2012. http://www.100tophospitals.com/assets/health_system_hospitals_perform_better.pdf

Prybil L and others. Governance in high-performing community health systems; a report on trustee and CEO views. Grant Thornton, 2009. http://www.nonprofithealthcare.org/resources/GovernanceInHigh-PerformingCommunityHealthSystems.pdf

2011 AHA health care governance survey report. AHA Center for Healthcare Governance, 2012. Available for sale at http://ams.aha.org/eweb/?ahabu=AMERICANGOVERNANCE

Dynamic governance: an analysis of board structure and practices in a shifting Industry.  2011 biennial survey of hospitals and healthcare systems.  Governance Institute, Fall 2011. Available for sale at http://www.governanceinstitute.com/ResearchPublications/ResourceLibrary/tabid/185/ProductID/1199/CategoryID/3/List/1/Level/a/Default.aspx?

Posted by AHA Resource Center, (312) 422.2050, rc@aha.org

Survey Results: Hospital Readiness for ACOs

The Health Research and Educational Trust, an affiliate of the American Hospital Association, conducted a survey of US hospitals in 2011 to determine their readiness for the development of accountable care organizations. A small percentage of hospitals was currently participating in an ACO [3%] or preparing to participate [10%]. Three-quarters of hospitals were not exploring the ACO model at the time.

The report also discusses the following, based on survey findings on hospital ACO activity:

  • ACO governance structure, including physician relationships
  • Legal structure of ACOs, including risk management ability and arrangements
  • ACO payment models, including capitation and pursuit of bundled payments
  • Partnerships and ability to provide primary, acute, and post-acute care
  • Care management, including patient population identification and assignment, population management, care coordination and transitions, and clinical information exchange
  • Performance reporting and quality improvement
  • Challenges and perceived barriers

Appended to the report is an ACO readiness assessment checklist to help organizations determine their progress on the ACO development journey.

Source: Hospital readiness for population-based accountable care. Health Research and Educational Trust, May 2012. http://www.hpoe.org/resources-and-tools/resources/Accountable_Care.pdf

Related source: Audet AJ and others. Hospitals on the path to accountable care: highlights from a 2011 national survey of hospital readiness to participate in an accountable care organization. Commonwealth Fund Issue Brief, vol. 22, Aug. 2012. http://www.commonwealthfund.org/Publications/Issue-Briefs/2012/Aug/Hospitals-on-the-Path-to-Accountable-Care.aspx

Posted by AHA Resource Center, (312) 422-2050, rc@aha.org